U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor recently discussed public trust in the court during an event in Louisville, Kentucky. She said that the court might have more public support if it took its time when overturning long-standing decisions. Sotomayor, who is part of the court’s liberal minority, explained that the current conservative-led court, reshaped by three justices nominated by former President Donald Trump, has made quick changes, such as overturning Roe v. Wade, which protected abortion rights, and ending affirmative action in college admissions.
While she didn’t directly discuss these specific rulings, Sotomayor said the public doesn’t like when the court moves too quickly with major changes. She believes this can cause confusion and instability, making people question whether the court’s decisions are based on law or political opinions. She added that while she doesn’t accuse her colleagues of being partisan, the public may perceive these changes as driven by personal beliefs.
Sotomayor argued that when the court acts too fast, it risks upsetting the public. She stressed that the court should move slowly when making big changes, especially when overturning past decisions, so the public can understand and accept them. She also defended the judiciary, saying it is one of the most transparent government branches because judges must explain their rulings in writing.
When asked about her role as a judge, Sotomayor shared that she enjoys being part of important decisions, even if she doesn’t always win. She believes that speaking out for what the law requires is important, and she values moments when she can convince her colleagues on legal matters. Though these moments have been rare recently, she said they still happen occasionally.
Sotomayor was in Louisville to receive the University of Louisville’s Brandeis Medal for her contributions to public service and justice. During the event, Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear also spoke, emphasizing that the Supreme Court’s duty is to rule impartially and serve the people, not just the powerful. Beshear, a potential future presidential candidate, reminded the audience that the rule of law is the foundation of a functioning democracy.
